Instead of: Grilled Cheese  Grilled cheese may be comforting, but the calorie and fat counts can get high, and fast. Instead, fill up your late-night sandwich with lean protein like turkey, add a few leafy greens, and top with just a bit of cheese. Make it panini-style, and you’ll still be able to enjoy the best part about a grilled cheese sandwich, but more healthfully. MORE: 10 Surprisingly Healthy Chocolate Recipes Instead of: Regular Peanut Butter  It may be full of healthy fats, but peanut butter still is also full of all those calories. Instead, whip up a batch of this lower-calorie raisin peanut butter to keep in your fridge for when the mood strikes. Come bedtime, top with banana slices for a filling treat. Instead of: Too Many Cookies  What’s better than cookie dough? One made without white flour and eggs! A FitSugar reader shared her recipe for healthier cookie dough balls with almond flour and lots of chocolate, of course. If you’re worried about the caffeine, use a semisweet chocolate instead of super dark. If you normally crave something sweet at night, make these beforehand and store in the fridge. MORE: Inflamation Fighting Tuna Shashimi Salad  Instead of: Pizza  Pizza is always a late-night (or anytime) favorite, but the grease and globs of cheese can not only undo a day of being healthy, but can also lead to a disruptive sleep. Ditch the heartburn and go for a tomatoey, cheesy meatball atop pita bread or crackers. Make this 120-calorie meatball recipe ahead of time and pop them in your fridge or freezer for an easy late-night treat. Instead of: Ice Cream  Sometimes you need ice cream, but if you find yourself constantly reaching for the pint, try making a few creamy snacks that’ll still satisfy you. Top a bowl of Greek yogurt with fresh fruit, or stir in frozen berries to make a semifrozen treat. Or, keep a few yogurt containers in your freezer. At night, thaw for a few minutes and add a drizzle of chocolate, fruit, or other toppings for a quick and easy fro-yo snack. MORE: The Foods Celebrity Trainers Won’t Eat