Try L’Oreal Paris HIP Color Truth Eyeliner Pencil in Navy ($8; drugstores), Physicians Formula Organic Wear Eyeliner in Black Olive ($8; drugstores), or Bobbi Brown Creamy Eye Pencil in Dusk ($20; bobbibrowncosmetics.com). Bobbi Brown is a celebrity makeup artist, CEO of Bobbi Brown Cosmetics, and the author of five beauty books.
